Français 
English
Español 
Started it after a rough week just to unwind, ended up more tense than when I began, worth it though
The community
What players actually say.
The ranking says which game wins, not why. The why is written on the game pages, one debate per game: here is where the conversation stands today.
Talking points
Debates of the moment
-
Resident Evil 41 messages 9 new -
Baldur's Gate III 49 messages 8 new What sets it apart for me is how much the world actually remembers you. Small choices from hours earlier come back in conversations you didn't expect, and that alone justifies the…
-
Halo: Reach 45 messages 7 new Why does this even beat Bulletstorm in duels
-
Uncharted 4: A Thief's End 16 messages 6 new Is it me, or does Uncharted 2 still get brought up more when people rank this one?
-
Kirby's Adventure 31 messages 6 new I keep seeing this ranked so highly and I just don't get it, the copy ability stuff is fun for like an hour and then it's basically the same screen over and over, and I know…
-
Ico 54 messages 6 new Sure, let's rank a PS2 game with a wonky camera above stuff built decades later with actual budgets, because apparently vibes outrank everything else on this site.
Upvoted
Most upvoted messages
-
cada vez que lo instalo de nuevo me sorprende lo bien que se sostiene el ritmo, para mí sigue siendo top 50 fácil
-
Anyone else still hum that codec ringtone at random moments for no reason at all? It's been decades and it just pops into my head.
-
What sticks with me most is how quiet it makes you play, even outside the game.
-
Un ranking que sube y baja según el humor de la gente esa semana, qué novedad... y aun así aquí seguimos discutiendo como si fuera ciencia exacta.
-
Débat sans fin, oui, mais moi j'ai encore mon perso de la première partie en tête, incroyable.
Straight from the games
Latest messages
-
Comparado con Uncharted, este juego tiene un tono mucho más duro y personal, aunque el mundo se siente más cerrado y menos variado en su recorrido.
-
También lo comparo cada vez y me cansa que sigan igualando esto con los GTA, no van ni de lejos por el mismo camino.
-
Why would that bother me? I spent one whole afternoon just running past shrines to reach a mountain.
-
Sí, así de simple, y ya me vale.
-
Why compare joy to cleverness though? Isn't that like asking which one deserves more respect?
-
Isn't it funny how ppl still mention Among Thieves first even in a thread about this one, does that mean the sequel never really closed that gap?
-
Nunca entendí del todo por qué se compara tanto con la segunda parte, tienen tonos distintos, aunque ambas tienen momentos altísimos
-
Le falta locura sí, pero la puesta en escena compensa buena parte de eso
-
van a decir que exagero pero para mí el "banger" se queda en el tráiler, la cámara y el inventario cansan a las dos horas.
-
Frente a lo que arriesgaba GTA IV en su momento, este prefirió pulir la fórmula, y ese pulido es justo lo que lo sostiene tantos años después
-
Yo también recuerdo esa primera tarde, y todavía vale la pena defenderlo aquí.
-
Mon fils préfère largement Tomb Raider
Everything left to say
Debates waiting to start
-
Pokémon Ruby Version
1,786 points
Start the debate →
-
Assassin's Creed Odyssey
1,784 points
Start the debate →
-
Mortal Kombat
1,774 points
Start the debate →
-
Sleeping Dogs
1,770 points
Start the debate →
-
Spider-Man 2
1,768 points
Start the debate →
-
Assassin's Creed Revelations
1,767 points
Start the debate →
Take part
How to join a debate
Reading and upvoting require nothing. Writing requires an account, so that a username stands behind what it posts.
1
Vote on a duel
Two games face off, you decide. Voting requires no account.
2
Open the winner page
Every game has its page, its statistics and its debate, right below its ranking.
3
Defend your pick
Post your take under your username, upvote other people, report anything out of line.
Upvoting and reporting stay open without an account. Posting and replying require signing up.
FAQ
Questions about debates
Do I need an account to write in a debate?
Yes: posting a message or replying to someone requires signing up, so that a username stands behind what it writes. Reading, upvoting a message and reporting abuse stay open without an account, under the same anonymous identity as voting.
What happens to a reported message?
It joins a moderation queue without disappearing: a report is an opinion, not a sanction. A message that does get hidden leaves the game page, this page and every counter at once, since all of them are counted at display time.
Can I read a message written in another language?
Yes. Debates are worldwide, just like the ranking: French, English and Spanish messages live in the same thread. A "Translate" button appears on those that are not in the language of the page, and the translation obtained then serves every reader.
Why is my message not on this page?
This page only shows a selection: the busiest game pages, the latest messages and the most upvoted ones. Your message is on the page of the game where you wrote it, and on your public profile, which gathers them all.