Français 
English
Español 
It rewards patience more than skill, and that balance still feels right to me.
The community
What players actually say.
The ranking says which game wins, not why. The why is written on the game pages, one debate per game: here is where the conversation stands today.
Talking points
Debates of the moment
-
Terraria 48 messages 19 new -
StarCraft 43 messages 19 new The balance between the three factions still holds up better than most strategy games try.
-
Mafia II 41 messages 19 new I keep coming back to how GOOD the period atmosphere feels, the cars, the radio, all of it, even if the open world itself barely gives you anything to do outside missions, which…
-
Max Payne 3 31 messages 18 new I keep coming back to defend this one every time it shows up in a duel and honestly I'm tired of repeating myself, but here we are again. It's still one of the tightest shooters…
-
Diablo 48 messages 17 new My uncle had this running on his PC and I just watched, mesmerized by how dark everything looked
-
Mass Effect 2 44 messages 17 new Oh sure, the loyalty missions are genius, said every review ever, yet half the squad still dies if you sneeze wrong.
Upvoted
Most upvoted messages
-
Me parece que sí, aunque igual me equivoco: un juego que sigue funcionando después de tantos años debería contar tanto como uno con mundo abierto y todo lo demás. No hace falta un mapa enorme para que algo importe, simplemente creo que el criterio no debería ser el tamaño de la experiencia sino cuánto dura las ganas de volver.
-
On me l'a vendu comme le chef d'oeuvre absolu, résultat j'ai passé plus de temps à choisir mon équipe qu'à jouer.
-
cada vez que hay un duelo contra Stardew Valley este gana facil, contra los otros dos ya es mas parejo, no se si el ranking refleja bien eso o es solo costumbre de voto
-
I'll admit I'm not neutral here, but next to Hades this one just rewards patience differently, and I'll pick that every time.
-
On y jouait chez mon oncle un dimanche sur deux, et ça reste gravé comme peu de choses.
Straight from the games
Latest messages
-
Ces fameux gimmicks de niveaux, ça reste varié mais la maniabilité rame un peu sur certains passages face à des jeux plus récents.
-
Sailed for hours once, no complaints
-
Same setup here with my roommate, except we did it with Shovel Knight too and the contrast between the two styles made both stand out more.
-
its concpet is great but the framerate hitches in some of the bigger open rooms really break the immersion for me
-
on Ico
Camera fights back at times.
-
The correction here isn't really a fix, or maybe it's more of a smoothing over, since the sailing pace complaint people keep bringing up was already there in the original design.
-
Melee rewards speed and reads that snowball fast, this rewards patience and a single correct read at the right moment, both demanding but in almost opposite ways
-
My roommate had it installed forever and I'd just watch him grind at 2am (never touched it myself back then)
-
I finished it during a move between apartments and it somehow made the chaos of boxes everywhere feel manageable, weirdly enough.
-
Got into it during a rough winter a couple years back, and tbh building random stuff at 2am helped more than it should have.
-
Je l'ai fini seul un dimanche pluvieux et j'étais plutôt content d'en sortir, pourquoi tu le trouves si sous-classé au juste ?
-
Ma sœur trouvait la caméra insupportable, moi ça me gênait pas, on n'a jamais réussi à se mettre d'accord dessus.
Everything left to say
Debates waiting to start
-
Far Cry 3
1,767 points
Start the debate →
-
The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings
1,756 points
Start the debate →
-
Crash Bandicoot 2: Cortex Strikes Back
1,754 points
Start the debate →
-
Grand Theft Auto: Vice City
1,752 points
Start the debate →
-
Shadow of the Tomb Raider
1,750 points
Start the debate →
-
Marvel's Spider-Man
1,746 points
Start the debate →
Take part
How to join a debate
Reading and upvoting require nothing. Writing requires an account, so that a username stands behind what it posts.
1
Vote on a duel
Two games face off, you decide. Voting requires no account.
2
Open the winner page
Every game has its page, its statistics and its debate, right below its ranking.
3
Defend your pick
Post your take under your username, upvote other people, report anything out of line.
Upvoting and reporting stay open without an account. Posting and replying require signing up.
FAQ
Questions about debates
Do I need an account to write in a debate?
Yes: posting a message or replying to someone requires signing up, so that a username stands behind what it writes. Reading, upvoting a message and reporting abuse stay open without an account, under the same anonymous identity as voting.
What happens to a reported message?
It joins a moderation queue without disappearing: a report is an opinion, not a sanction. A message that does get hidden leaves the game page, this page and every counter at once, since all of them are counted at display time.
Can I read a message written in another language?
Yes. Debates are worldwide, just like the ranking: French, English and Spanish messages live in the same thread. A "Translate" button appears on those that are not in the language of the page, and the translation obtained then serves every reader.
Why is my message not on this page?
This page only shows a selection: the busiest game pages, the latest messages and the most upvoted ones. Your message is on the page of the game where you wrote it, and on your public profile, which gathers them all.