← Voir la fiche

Le débat sur Disco Elysium: The Final Cut

Ce que la communauté pense de Disco Elysium: The Final Cut, dans l'ordre du soutien des lecteurs. Approuver, traduire et signaler un message ne demandent aucun compte.

39 commentaires

Publier nécessite un compte : connexion ou inscription.

  1. CapucineHunter

    Non, il ne triche pas avec des dialogues creux comme certains le prétendent. C'est un jeu qui prend le risque de miser sur l'écriture pure, et ça mérite d'être reconnu à sa juste valeur, pas relégué derrière des jeux plus courts et plus simples juste parce qu'ils sont plus faciles à digérer.

  2. GlitchPilot

    Pour moi c'est le récit qui porte tout, l'écriture est d'un autre niveau. Ça justifie largement sa présence dans le classement.

    Audrey_55

    Only got a few sessions in, and the writing is sharp, sure, but I don't think that alone earns it a spot this high over games with tighter design.

  3. lacombe_pierre

    Face à Undertale, qui arrive à toucher avec presque rien, est-ce que Disco Elysium ne mise pas un peu trop sur son volume de texte pour paraître profond ?

    CoopAce

    The skill checks dress up as depth but mechanically they're just dice rolls with better writing on top.

  4. Reichel2009

    Played it during a rough winter. Don't remember much else from that season.

    GerhardByte

    rough winter, sure, but boring is boring, don't dress it up as atmosphere

    AllieRider

    En réponse à GerhardByte

    Voice acting helps a ton but the interface still shows its age, menus feel clunky when you're switching skills mid dialogue.

  5. NeonDragon

    The politics stuff alone makes it worth defending, honestly, way more nuanced than most games even attempt.

  6. Kris94

    Replayed it last year expecting the writing to feel dated or overhyped in hindsight, and it really doesn't, the dialogue system still runs circles around most RPGs releasing today.

    BossNinja1986

    I felt the same skepticism going in, but the writing won me over faster than I expected it to.

    Nova_Pagan

    En réponse à BossNinja1986

    Curioso que hable de dientes de leche o algo así, no me acuerdo, pero sí, la diferencia está en el ritmo con el que uno lee cada línea.

    CoopKnight4

    Firewatch never asked this much of the player, and it shows in replay value.

    prohaska_geraldine

    Second playthrough or not, I still think it's carried by hype more than by actual replay value.

  7. lfarrell

    130 duels and a 48% win rate feels low for something people call a masterpiece so often, makes me wonder if the fanbase is louder than it is big.

  8. Vergie_62

    Why does a game this dense in choices still manage to never feel like homework?

    BossPilot2

    Denso sí, pero denso no significa tarea. Es distinto llevar el peso de una historia que arrastrar texto de relleno.

  9. CoopPhoenix2010

    Diálogos brillantes. Con eso me basta para defenderlo.

    Homenick28

    If the dialogue alone is enough for you, doesn't that prove the rest of the game barely needed to exist?

  10. McClure30

    loved the writing, combat system barely exists tho

    RustyRider

    combat barely exists, or plutôt it just isn't the point, and that's fine by me

  11. SaveByte40

    honestly, 394th feels about right and I'm tired of people acting like it's a scandal. it's a good game with a lot of talking, not the second coming of the RPG genre.

    OcéaneOwl

    En réponse à Tressa_2000

    j'ai surtt retenu le froid et l'ennui, tt le contraire de ce qu'on me promettait sur ce jeu franchement

    azemlak

    Compared to Firewatch, this actually lets your choices pile up into something. Isn't that worth more than a scandal?

    ArcadeMaster

    En réponse à mazie25

    No hace falta pelear con nadie para decir que un diálogo bueno no siempre hace un buen juego completo.

    LootAce

    Diré lo que pienso aunque no guste: me pasó lo mismo que a otros, tres horas y ya quería dejarlo, sin más

    Tressa_2000

    Rough winter or not, I just remember being bored stiff during the slower stretches, that's my whole experience with it.

    Rocky_24

    Is it really talking heads though, or just dialogue with more weight than combat

    mazie25

    I get the tiredness, but the first time a skill check argued with itself in my head, I was completely hooked.

  12. FrameKid

    mucho hype para un juego que es básicamente leer todo el rato

  13. BossDragon2

    Only put in a few hours, didn't feel the hype everyone talks about.

  14. edwardo_schulist

    Does the writing actually hold up on a second playthrough, or does the novelty of the skill checks carry most of the first one? Genuinely asking.

    GhostByte2

    Peut-être, mais le texte seul ne fait pas tout le jeu.

    Tromp53

    Second playthrough doesn't fix pacing that drags the first time either.

  15. LuckyMaster

    Sobrevalorado. Muchas palabras, poco juego.

    Carolina_55

    Undertale still says more with a bark than half the dialogue trees here manage in three pages.

Voter sur un duel