← View the game page

The StarCraft debate

What the community thinks of StarCraft, ordered by reader support. Agreeing, translating and reporting a message need no account.

43 comments

Posting requires an account: log in or sign up.

  1. karina32

    The balance between the three factions still holds up better than most strategy games try.

  2. NovaPlayer15

    I think it deserves a higher spot, though I could be wrong about how it compares to newer strategy games.

    ratke_candido

    Watching my roommate lose to the AI on the easiest setting was somehow the highlight of our week.

  3. JazlynMaster

    My son picked Warcraft III over this in ten minutes flat.

    davis_lelah

    lol same energy here, my nephew picked WC3 too, guess the trend crosses generations and continents apparently.

  4. QuestRunner25

    wait, 46th with a 79% win rate? this ranking makes no sense to me honestly

    ArcadeOwl

    I had the exact same doubt after checking a few of its matchups against shooters, feels like comparing apples to something else entirely.

  5. Coop_Ferrer

    Perder contra Call of Duty en estos duelos me parece un chiste (sin ofender a nadie), son publicos totalmente distintos.

    QuestMaster

    different audiences, sure, so why does the algorithm keep pitting them against each other duel after duel?

  6. FrameKid

    pa mi sigue siendo de lo mejor que a dado el genero, la base esta ahi y se nota

    casas_ander

    la base sigue siendo la base, pero el pulido de otros juegos actuales se nota, y se nota bastante

  7. Ghost_Collet

    Il mérite largement sa place, rien à ajouter.

    SilentMaster

    Agreed, though what I remember most is losing my first campaign mission on repeat before it clicked.

  8. SilviaAce

    Me da la impresión de que se sostiene mejor en las campañas que en el online actual, aunque puede que solo sea porque yo ya no juego online como antes, no sé si a alguien más le pasa lo mismo con estos juegos viejos.

  9. NeonRider1987

    Jugaba con mi hermano mayor y no entendiamos ni la mitad de las mecanicas, pero ahí seguíamos.

    IronKnight2004

    we played co-op on the same team and it was pure chaos, honeslty best kind

    SilentRunner

    jugabas tambien tu con tu hermano o eras el unico raro que le daba a esto de pequeño?

  10. lacombe_pierre

    Est-ce que le classement récompense vraiment la stratégie pure, ou juste le nombre de joueurs qui votent par habitude ?

    gmosciski

    honestly this thread made me remember the exact desk I had when I first tried the campaign, weird what sticks

  11. Marina_8

    Contra Warcraft III gana siempre para mi, sin duda ninguna.

    edwardo_schulist

    does it really beat Warcraft III on merit or just because older votes shaped the ranking early on?

    VinylMaster

    fr, same exact scenario here, no contest tbh, WC3 never had a chance in my games.

  12. RogueNinja62

    Encore un duel contre Warcraft III et encore le même débat, bon, je vote pour lui quand même.

    GhostSamurai

    Same energy tbh, my cousin also keeps voting out of habit, at least he's honest about it.

    NeonKnight12

    Replying to GhostSamurai

    Le vote par habitude, ça ne prouve rien pour le classement.

    SaveLegend2

    Voting out of habit against Warcraft III makes sense to me, but does that habit hold up if you actually replay both back to back?

  13. CoopPhoenix2010

    Sigue firme frente a Warcraft III, eso lo tengo CLARO.

    GhostByte2

    Warcraft III a son charme, mais lui il a la rigueur en plus.

  14. Océane_1987

    L'interface de gestion des unités a vraiment vieilli, le tri par groupe reste laborieux comparé à ce qui existe maintenant, ça freine plus qu'on ne le pense.

    CoopAce

    The unit tray hasn't aged well but once you set control groups it barely matters anymore

    VinylOwl

    Replying to CoopAce

    Once I learned the hotkeys it clicked the same way, night and day difference.

    Manzano69

    esa comparación con warcraft me hace pensar que quizás el problema no es la interfaz sino la costumbre que tenemos con lo nuevo

    Pagac35

    Same issue here, though once you set your groups early it stops being a real problem.

    CoopKnight4

    Replying to Pagac35

    Setting control groups early solves most of it honestly, and once you're past that the pacing carries the rest.

    ratke_matilda

    The tray never bothered me that much, I just remember setting groups on instinct after a few matches, felt natural fast...

    wrodarte

    pa mi ese tourniquet ya cansa, la verdad.

  15. Carpentier2010

    Face à Warcraft III il garde une identité plus dure, plus exigeante, l'autre a toujours semblé plus accessible en comparaison.