← View the game page

The The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild debate

What the community thinks of The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild, ordered by reader support. Agreeing, translating and reporting a message need no account.

36 comments

Posting requires an account: log in or sign up.

  1. qstanton

    The shrines get repetitive fast, and I never understood why that gets a pass from everyone.

  2. Madyson_88

    it's beautiful and the freedom is real, but the durability system alone makes me question why it sits this high

    Aaron_85

    Puede que la durabilidad moleste al principio, pero con el tiempo me acostumbré y hasta lo agradecí en ciertos combates

    davis_lelah

    The durability thing never bothered me, but I get the complaint, in Portal you never lose your one tool halfway through a puzzle.

  3. BossRex

    How does it even compare fairly to something like Portal, when one is about a giant open world and the other about a single tight loop?

    CoopKnight4

    The fair way to compare them is probably by how well each one respects your time once you understand the rules, not by scale.

    CritRunner70

    Replying to CoopKnight4

    Ah sí, la comparación perfecta, un juego de cajas y otro de montañas, muy justo todo.

  4. BerryRunner

    Oh sure, I remember it well, mostly the tree I fell off for the twentieth time in a row.

    ÁngelesSamurai

    Con Portal me acuerdo de resolver todo en silencio, aquí grité de emoción al caerme de un acantilado sin querer.

  5. SaveHunter

    I picked it up during a slow week at work, just to try the intro, and ended up ignoring most of my actual plans that month.

    Rae_1990

    Same thing here, or rather worse, I told my roommate two days and vanished for a month.

  6. ArcadeOwl

    Replayed it last month with fresh eyes instead of nostalgia, and it mostly holds up, the combat variety still feels thin compared to what's out now.

  7. Alaina_61

    Second place, ELO 1973, or rather it's been sitting there so long it feels like a permanent address rather than a ranking.

    IronKnight2004

    My roommate watched me climb every tower before dinner, week after week, and honestly calling this spot a permanent address ignores how much time people actually put into it together.

    Lucy_20

    La physique des matériaux tient encore bien aujourd'hui, tu trouves pas ?

    dominique_rolland

    Il m'a accompagné tout un hiver difficile, ce qui compte plus pour moi que sa place exacte.

    WallaceKnight

    But didn't you ever get attached to a weapon right before it broke on you, or is that just me being sentimental about pixels?

  8. TurboByte47

    Je l'ai découvert chez un ami un dimanche pluvieux, et contrairement à Ocarina of Time j'ai eu l'impression de rentrer dans un monde plutôt qu'un couloir.

    QuestLegend2

    wait, "world" over "corridor" pretty much sums the whole debate on this thread tbh, ppl keep voting like it's a coin flip

    Hebert49

    Ocarina en couloir, c'est osé mais je le pense aussi...

  9. PedroHunter

    Segundo puesto es su lugar de siempre, y ya se ha vuelto un poco previsible discutir sobre lo mismo cada vez.

  10. FrameLegend2010

    Lo empecé en un viaje largo con mi hermano mirando por encima del hombro, y comparado con Ocarina se sentía como otro juego totalmente.

    yleannon

    Total opposite feeling for me, since when does a sequel feel like a stranger to its own series?

  11. NeonRider

    Segundo lugar, otra vez, y sinceramente ya ni me sorprende ni me emociona defenderlo cada vez.

    TurboByte

    (à part ça) je trouve le classement franchement généreux avec lui.

    PixelSamurai

    Je le défends encore à chaque duel, même fatigué du débat, parce que je m'en souviens comme d'un vrai dépaysement.

    Antonette_77

    Second place forever apparently, at some point the vote count says more about us than the game.

  12. FrameKid2

    Lo jugué después de terminarme uno de los Zelda clásicos y la diferencia de libertad se siente muchísimo, aunque no siempre fue perfecto para mí.

    RogueRider2008

    La liberté totale, ça compense quoi face à Ocarina, la nostalgie ?

  13. ThéophileSamurai

    deuxième place avec un tel taux de victoires, c'est presque une anomalie statistique qu'il ne soit pas premier, et je me demande combien de duels contre Ocarina il a perdus pour rester coincé là.

    SilviaAce

    Segundo lugar, otra vez, y esa anomalía estadística ya casi es tradición del hilo

  14. GlitchOwl95

    Deux minutes, une arme cassée, la routine.

  15. GlitchPilot

    Trois étés de suite dessus, et je n'ai toujours pas tout vu.

    barton_alaina

    Replying to ArcadeAce4

    Big map, sure, but or rather empty in spots when you actually explore it.

    ArcadeAce4

    Three summers and still finding stuff, that's not repetition, that's just a big map